Book Review: Feminist Movements in India

Sadhna Arya’s and Lata Singh’s Feminist Movements in India is a comprehensive examination of the evolution of feminism in the Indian context. It explores the historical, social, and political dimensions of feminist struggles, emphasising the intersectionality of caste, class, and gender. The book critically assesses the movement’s trajectory, from the colonial period to contemporary times, shedding light on the contributions of women’s organisations, grassroots activism, and policy changes.

Also Read: Nexus by Yuval Noah Harari: A Critical Examination of the Threat AI Poses to Humanity

Key Themes and Analysis

1. Historical Evolution of Feminism in India

Sadhna Arya traces the origins of feminist thought in India, beginning with social reform movements of the 19th and early 20th centuries. She discusses the contributions of reformers like Raja Ram Mohan Roy, Ishwar Chandra Vidyasagar, and Savitribai Phule in advocating for women’s education, widow remarriage, and the abolition of practices like Sati. The role of nationalist women leaders, such as Sarojini Naidu and Kasturba Gandhi, in the independence movement is also highlighted.

The book argues that while these reform movements sought to improve women’s conditions, they were often led by upper-caste men who framed women’s issues through a paternalistic lens. Sadhna Arya & Lata Singh critically examine how the early feminist movement was shaped by both colonial and nationalist narratives, sometimes sidelining the concerns of marginalised women.

2. Post-Independence Feminist Movements

Arya & Singh provide an in-depth analysis of the feminist resurgence in the 1970s and 1980s, influenced by global feminist movements and socialist ideologies. They discuss key moments such as:

• The publication of the Towards Equality report (1974), which exposed gender disparities in education, employment, and health.
• The rise of autonomous women’s organisations addressing issues like dowry deaths, rape laws, and domestic violence.
• The Shah Bano case (1985) and its impact on debates around personal laws and women’s rights.

A major strength of the book is its critique of mainstream feminism for often overlooking caste and class issues. Sadhna Arya highlights the role of Dalit and Adivasi women’s movements in challenging both patriarchy and upper-caste dominance within feminist circles.

3. Intersectionality: Caste, Class, and Gender

One of the most compelling aspects of the book is focus on intersectionality. The authors argue that Indian feminism cannot be understood in isolation from caste and class structures. The book discusses:

• How Dalit feminism challenges both upper-caste oppression and gender discrimination.
• The struggles of working-class women in labor movements, especially in unorganised sectors.
• The role of Muslim women in feminist activism, particularly in the context of debates around the Uniform Civil Code and personal laws.

Authors critiques the mainstream feminist movement for being largely urban and upper-caste, often failing to engage with the realities of rural and marginalised women. They highlight how movements like the Bharatiya Dalit Mahila Andolanand the National Federation of Dalit Women have played a crucial role in redefining feminism in India.

Also Read: Book Trends: 5 Must-Reads for Women This Season

4. Legal and Policy Changes

The book examines how feminist activism has influenced legal reforms in India. Arya discusses:

• The Criminal Law (Amendment) Act, 1983, which strengthened laws against rape and dowry.
• The Vishaka Guidelines (1997) on sexual harassment at the workplace.
• The Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005.

Sadhna Arya & Lata Singh also critiques the gaps in implementation, arguing that legal changes often do not translate into real change due to systemic patriarchy within law enforcement and judiciary structures.

5. Contemporary Challenges and the Future of Feminism

The book discusses the rise of digital feminism, the role of social media in mobilising protests (such as the #MeToo movement in India), and the impact of neoliberal policies on women’s rights. She raises concerns about the increasing backlash against feminism from right-wing groups and patriarchal structures, highlighting the need for a more inclusive and intersectional approach.

Strengths of the Book

• Well-researched and comprehensive: Arya’s book is deeply rooted in historical and sociological research, providing a nuanced understanding of feminist movements in India.
• Intersectional approach: Unlike many earlier feminist works, Arya’s analysis includes caste, class, and religious diversity.
• Critical perspective: The book does not shy away from critiquing mainstream feminist movements, making it a valuable resource for those looking to understand the gaps within Indian feminism.

Criticisms

• Dense academic language: The book is highly theoretical, making it less accessible to general readers unfamiliar with feminist theory.
• Limited discussion on LGBTQ+ issues: While the book covers intersectionality, it does not extensively address queer and transgender rights within the feminist movement.
  Conclusion

Also Read: Book Review: Exploring ‘Mandeep Meets Mandeep’ by Sona Sharma

Feminist Movements in India is an essential read for anyone interested in gender studies, Indian history, and social activism. It provides a critical, well-researched perspective on the evolution of feminism in India, highlighting both achievements and ongoing challenges. While the book may be academic in tone, its insights are invaluable for activists, students, and policymakers alike.